Ann Arbor Weather:
Sunday October 24, 2021
Follow us: facebook twitter RSS feed

Everyone's a Critic

The Observer's culture blog

Thursday, June 27, 2013


Cover of the book Detroit: An American Autopsy, by Charlie LeDuff

'I reached down the pants cuff with the eraser end of my pencil and poked it. Frozen solid. But definitely human." And so Charlie LeDuff begins Detroit: An American Autopsy, non-fiction that often reads like a noir thriller.

LeDuff, then a Detroit News reporter, was called to the abandoned building to witness a gruesome sight: a corpse at the bottom of an elevator shaft, encased in ice —"his legs sticking out like Popsicle sticks." The story becomes a media sensation but in this dysfunctional city, a day passes before anything is done with the corpse--in life, a likeable panhandler known as "Johnnie Dollar." For LeDuff, his fate is a macabre metaphor for the ruin of his hometown.

LeDuff came back to Detroit after a stint at the New York Times; he claims he quit because his bosses there complained that he was only interested in "losers." A cover blurb says he returned to "discover what destroyed his city." But while LeDuff ticks off the usual list of economic and historic forces—the shortsighted auto bosses, the riots of '67 and the subsequent flight of the (mostly white) middle class, the cronyism and corrupt politics—he is essentially a storyteller. And because his family's troubles are hard to separate from the city's, his stories mix reportage with memoir.

For years, his mother valiantly tried to keep her downtown flower shop open, through armed robberies, arson, and vandalism, before finally moving her business to affluent Grosse Pointe. His sister became a streetwalker, a familiar sight in certain Detroit bars, then died in a car crash. A niece died from drugs; his brother lost his job in the (sub-prime) mortgage business and ended up in a low-paid job cleaning screws manufactured in China. And LeDuff isn't detached from the pain. A domestic brawl with his wife landed him in a jail cell: "I felt bad, hollow," he writes. "A middle-aged fuckup crumbling under the bulk of a dying city."

LeDuff is a strong writer, in a Hemingway, tough-guy mode. But wondering if Detroit really did his family in, or if they would have struggled anyway, I found the personal stories less absorbing than his gutsy investigative reporting.

LeDuff follows a paper trail to see why $20 million to fix up a police precinct and firehouse never found its way there. "The floors … were cracked, the heat didn't work and water pipes to fill the fire engines were forgotten." Things get scary when he reports the killing of a murder witness—but his work pays off when, to everyone's surprise, the judge doesn't dismiss the case. "Your article put a lot of pressure on everybody," she tells him. Three people actually do time.

When seven-year-old Aiyama is accidentally killed by a cop in a police raid, the physician doing the autopsy tells LeDuff that the girl died from the "psychopathology of growing up in Detroit. Some people are doomed from birth because their environment is so toxic." Tragic as they are, the stories of Aiyama and so many other lost Detroiters deserve to be told. Few recently have told them better than LeDuff.

Posted by John Hilton at 7:10 p.m. | 0 comments Bookmark and Share


Post a comment:


Your e-mail address: (will not be shown)

Your name:

Please enter the word hello here, to show that you are a human and not a spam robot:

Blog comments are reviewed and edited by the Observer staff and are not guaranteed to be shown on the website.

Previous Posts

You might also like:

Dixboro House Tests Its Wings with Prepaid Dinners
But nightly service won't happen anytime soon.
Micheline Maynard
Surviving the Pandemic
Hard work, loyal customers, and PPP grants got the city's oldest restaurants through the storm.
Micheline Maynard
Remembering Professor Don Cameron, by Jeffrey A. Stacey
Nightspots: Habitat Lounge
Restaurants - Bars & Brew Pubs
Finding a Farmers' Market
How specialized sellers from near and far pick their spots.
Micheline Maynard, with research by L.R. Nunez
Subscribe to the Ann Arbor Observer
Writing Coach
When Adam Was spent the biggest game of the season on the bench, he was "hurt and confused."
Jan Schlain
Public Schools - High Schools
Back to School 2021
The public schools and the U-M are fully reopening. What will that look like-and will it be safe?
James Leonard and Jan Schlain
a2view the Ann Arbor Observer's weekly email newsletter
ann arbor summer festival