Ann Arbor Observer cover
Tattoos for Avalon Housing
Ann Arbor Weather:
Saturday October 19, 2019
Follow us: facebook twitter RSS feed
Hannah Arendt movie still

Hannah Arendt

More than a biopic

by James M. Manheim

From the November, 2013 issue

Hannah Arendt, a film about the mid-century German Jewish philosopher who examined the roots of totalitarianism, transports the viewer into a late-1950s world of intellectual New York cocktail parties enveloped in swirling cigarette smoke, to the offices of the New Yorker magazine during the period (British actor Nicholas Woodeson's portrayal of the magazine's legendary editor, William Shawn, is pretty much worth the admission price in itself), and of Arendt's own very lively marriage. Arendt fled Nazi Germany, was held for a time in a French concentration camp, and finally made her way to the United States, where she became a naturalized citizen. The level of Mad Men period detail is astonishing, especially for a director, Margarethe von Trotta, who is not American but German.

Von Trotta and her lead actress, Barbara Sukowa, bring fully to life this woman who came face to face with the worst the twentieth century had to offer and tried to bring the philosophical tradition to bear upon it. Sukowa's performance is Oscar worthy: her Arendt, chain-smoking, cutting off anyone deemed unworthy of her intellectual respect, is an unforgettable character. Arendt in the film brings up the touchy subject of some Jewish leaders' collaboration with the Nazis in the early years of Hitler's rule, and she is not much of a Jewish nationalist. "You know I don't love any people--how can I be expected to love the Jews?" she asks.

But Hannah Arendt can't really be called a biopic, and it is more than a vivid evocation of a fascinating and historically significant figure. The film focuses largely on a single episode in Arendt's life: the period in the early 1960s when she wrote for the New Yorker about the trial of Nazi leader Adolf Eichmann in Jerusalem, and on the backlash her writing triggered.

In deftly incorporated historical footage, we see the nondescript Eichmann's testimony, in which he basically said that he was just following orders and thus couldn't be considered guilty of the

...continued below...


crimes with which he had been charged. In describing Eichmann, Arendt hit upon the phrase "the banality of evil."

By now it has become a familiar idea, but at the time, with the Holocaust just a few years in the past, it was incendiary. Arendt seemed to suggest that the Nazi evil was not of an absolute, unique kind but instead something that might be carried out by any obedient functionary--by any of us, really. Arendt lost close friends, the New Yorker was deluged with angry mail, and there were calls for her dismissal from her academic posts. The film's climactic scenes consist of a lecture in which she defends herself against her detractors.

Hannah Arendt is a film about ideas and about a woman sitting at her desk, writing--both tall orders for a filmmaker. But when the film, in a mixture of English and German, had its local premiere at last spring's Cinetopia film festival, showings in the main theater at the Michigan were almost packed, and it drew strong crowds at the Detroit Institute of Arts in September. Its monologue climax had the Michigan Theater crowd applauding. Hannah Arendt returns to the Michigan on November 2 and 3.     (end of article)

[Originally published in November, 2013.]

 

 
Bookmark and Share
Print Comment E-mail

You might also like:

Comedy
Train Delays
Slow progress on high-speed rail
James Leonard
Is This the Year?
Last football season ended in humiliation. Now things could be looking up.
Craig Ross
The Terraplanes
Local institution
James M. Manheim
Sugar Town
Randy Tessier channels Nancy Sinatra.
James Leonard
Sweetwaters Grows
Ryan Harrah thought that introducing Sweetwaters to South Carolina might take a while.
Micheline Maynard
Lisa Robert's Busy Summer
Rock Paper Scissors arrives in Saline
Billie Ochberg
Snuff Stories from East Quad
A lurid U-M case tested free speech when the Internet was young.
Greg Stejskal
Nightspots: Zal Gaz Grotto
Subscribe to the Ann Arbor Observer
One of the finest university art museums in the country, UMMA holds collections representing 150 yea
Vicki's Wash and Wear Haircuts