Ann Arbor Weather:
Wednesday December 01, 2021
Follow us: facebook twitter RSS feed
film still from El Mar La Mar

El Mar La Mar

Beauty and ruin at the border

by Patrick Dunn

From the November, 2019 issue

There's slow-burning horror in the lengthy opening shot of J.P. Sniadecki and Joshua Bonnetta's film El Mar La Mar. It at first seems to depict an indeterminate natural landscape split into multiple small images by some sort of prismatic effect, with a moving camera creating a sense of ecstatic energy. As the camera slowly pulls back, it's revealed that we're actually peering through the tall bars of a section of border wall, fragmenting our view of the Sonoran Desert beyond.

This interplay of natural beauty with stark reality is the bread and butter of Sniadecki and Bonnetta's hypnotic, disturbing portrait of life-and gruesome death-along the U.S.-Mexico border. The filmmakers' narrative couches the hot-button issue of immigration in uniquely elemental terms. Rather than casting the issue in terms of Americans versus Mexicans, or border patrol versus asylum seekers, the film's great antagonist is the desert itself.

Sniadecki and Bonnetta compose painterly shots of sunsets and moonrises over the sandy expanse, but their interview subjects return time and again to the horrors the desert holds for those attempting to cross it. Multiple voices discuss how easily footprints are blown away by the wind. One man, speaking in Spanish, describes getting separated from his group while attempting to cross the border on foot because he stayed behind to help an old man who fainted in the heat. "You get lost because you don't know where you are," the man says.

People also tell stories of stumbling across dead bodies in the sand. "For me, the thing that just enraged me was how something so horrible was no different than the various cattle corpses we'd come across in the field," one woman says.

None of the film's interview subjects are seen onscreen. Their haunting tales are often accompanied by a black screen, or more landscape footage. There are long wordless stretches too. In these, the only sound is the ambient hum of desert wind or buzzing insects, while the camera lingers on unsettling

...continued below...

details like faded clothes left behind in the desert or the water jugs that activists leave out for thirsty migrants.

Sniadecki and Bonnetta's sympathies are clearly with the immigrants, but they make a smart decision in casting the desert itself as their film's focal point. By denying us even a glimpse of their interview subjects' faces, the filmmakers strip away some of the prejudices we might assign to them, placing them all on the same side of a battle against the elements. In uniquely compelling terms, they raise one of the most relevant questions in the ongoing immigration debate: what horrors at home would prompt someone to contend with such an utterly unforgiving swath of nature?

The film screens November 6 at the State Theatre as part of the Ann Arbor Film Festival's "AAFF Presents" series.     (end of article)

[Originally published in November, 2019.]


Bookmark and Share
Print Comment E-mail

You might also like:

Restaurants that are Disability Friendly
A clickable zoomable map
Remembering Professor Don Cameron, by Jeffrey A. Stacey
Tyrone Hicks
Lessons in life and basketball
Shelley Daily
Community Services - Food and Housing
Edgefest at 25
Celebrating innovative movements in jazz
Piotr Michalowski
Nightspots: Ypsi Alehouse
Photo: Brian and Greg Open Stadium Hardware by the Dawn's Early Light.
Subscribe to the Ann Arbor Observer
Elementary Schools
Crime Map
A clickable, zoomable map
a guide to local holiday shopping and events
a2view the Ann Arbor Observer's weekly email newsletter